Mixed messages make interfaces unintuitive

Get RSS

Posted by Jackie Kingsley on 04 Aug 2010 at 12:37

Categories : copy writing

If you live or work in London, you’ll be familiar with the routine of topping up your Oyster travel card using Transport for London’s machines. Once you’ve paid for your top-up, this message appears on the screen: “Please wait…your Oyster card has been updated”.

The amazing thing about this message is its power to confuse even when you’ve seen it hundreds of times before. Because the words appear on the same screen at the same time, there are always a few seconds (more, if you’re an Oyster newbie) when you hesitate: has your card has been updated or should you wait? Meanwhile an impatient queue is forming behind you. Maybe one day a bright spark from TfL will come up with a message that actually says what it means – that you’ve topped up your Oyster card and can now get out of the way and let everyone else have a turn.

The problem with the Oyster message is that it pulls the reader in two directions – much as websites do if they put links in the middle of sentences. What is the user supposed to do if they come across a link that interrupts their reading? Read on, or follow the link? If they follow the link will they come back? And if they hesitate too long, will they give up altogether?

This isn’t a situation you want to put your readers in, so do them a favour – put your links at the end of sentences. Then they can finish what they’re reading and follow the link at their leisure. Like us Oyster card users, they’ll be grateful to you for making their journey a little smoother.

Close X

Share this story

Share with third party communities This will take you to a new window.

Comments

Ian Waugh
05 Aug 2010 at 10:35

Really interesting Jackie. I had a Eureka moment when I first thought of not putting hyperlinks in my text I thought I had stumbled across a great truth that would help my readers immensely. A couple of years on though, I’m not sure it’s that clear cut. After seeing some fascinating eye-tracking studies from Nielsen/Norman group, I can see the value of hyperlinks as a form of ‘information scent’, allowing users to scan a piece and pick up the meaning quickly. Also, I’m instinctively wary about trying to get in the way of users leaving my website, if that’s what they want to do. If they find my content useful and compelling, they’ll read on… if not they’ll leave anyway. I guess it depends on a lot of factors, the purpose of the content for one thing. Plenty of investigation and reading to be done on this one!

Please dont take my hyperlinks away Ensign Jens personal log
05 Aug 2010 at 10:35

similar subject was covered within a blog post from content agency Sticky Content, titled ‘Mixed messages make interfaces unintuitive’. Both posts suggest that by placing links within the text, you are presenting the user

www.stickycontent.co.uk @www.stickycontent.co.uk
02 Apr 2011 at 23:35

Mixed messages make interfaces unintuitive.. Tiptop :)

www.stickycontent.co.uk @www.stickycontent.co.uk
22 Apr 2011 at 13:41

Mixed messages make interfaces unintuitive.. Peachy :)

www.stickycontent.co.uk @www.stickycontent.co.uk
03 Jun 2011 at 00:32

Mixed messages make interfaces unintuitive.. I like it :)

www.stickycontent.co.uk @www.stickycontent.co.uk
05 Jun 2011 at 00:53

Mixed messages make interfaces unintuitive.. Neat :)

www.stickycontent.co.uk @www.stickycontent.co.uk
12 Jun 2011 at 09:04

Mixed messages make interfaces unintuitive.. OMG! :)

1ks4 pon videos u8xy @1ks4 pon videos u8xy
02 Jul 2011 at 06:37

Mixed messages make interfaces unintuitive.. Ho-o-o-o-t :)

n6q7 sex wrmb @n6q7 sex wrmb
02 Jul 2011 at 23:58

Mixed messages make interfaces unintuitive.. Outstanding :)

Add a comment to this entry